24 January 2009

The Office: Prince Family Paper

In the latest episode of The Office, Michael is sent on a mission to find out about a competitive paper firm.  On his mission he takes the ever corky Dwight.  As they are about to go into the other paper company, Michael goes on and on to the camera about business being "survival of the fittest" in which the big shark, eats the littler shark, and so on until the tiniest organism shark is eaten.  He sees business from a clearly empirical standpoint.  It is all competition and greed.  Part of your businesses purpose is to take down other businesses on the road to success.  
However, as Michael enters the office, he realizes that it is a very family oriented business.  They only people that work there are the owner, his wife, and his son.  They have a large client base, but are completely dependent on their companies success for their well being.  These people are very kind to Michael, offering him coffee, helping him fix his car, and telling him all about their business.  They trust Michael.  Eventually, the owner of the Prince Family Paper company gives Michael their entire list of top clients.  This is the best possible result that Michael could have hoped for, and his boss would be very pleased.  However, after getting to know the Prince family, Michael realizes that he doesn't want to give the list to his boss because he knows that it will hurt the Prince family's business.  
In this part, Michael represents the kingdom.  "Live, and let live!"  he exclaims to Dwight, when Dwight insists that they should give the list to their boss.  Michael realizes in this moment that business is not solely about competition.  He realizes that business can be personal.  People's livelihoods are invested in their businesses, and when bigger corporations take them down, they are ruined.  Michael doesn't believe that competition should completely drive a company.  He recognizes the greed of this own company when he says "our sales our fine!  we dont need this clients!"  
However, Dwight is a representation of the empire in this episode.  Dwight is bound and determined that they must give the client list to their boss.  He says that it is the best thing for the company, and the Prince Family Paper company is weak and does not deserve to be in business.  After an epic chase around the office and a struggle for the list, Dwight eventually snatches the list from Michael, and forces his hand in calling their boss.  After Michael gives into the empirical values, Dwight comforts him by saying "guess who's stock just went up!"  to which Michael replies with "It bittersweet".  
This episode of The Office is a great example of the conflict between to empire and the kingdom.  It questions the way that the empire does business.  Big companies are notorious for taking small businesses clients and putting those companies out of business.  And they are driven by greed and competition, a perfect example of empirical values.  Unfortunately in this episode, and for much of the real business world, the empire wins.  

7 comments:

  1. I WAS THINKING THE EXACT SAME THING WHILE I WAS WATCHING THIS.
    crazy. anyways, i feel like this episode is a prime example of the Empire vs. the Kingdom.
    The contrast of dwight and michael is very well portrayed as the two battling forces. it's very disappointing that the Empire does end up winning in the end, even after michael feels guilty.
    His realization of the consequences of his actions are elements of the kingdom shining through.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This episode was so funny. I never really watched The Office looking for a deeper meaning, but once I read this I could totally see the tension between the Empire and the Kingdom. I think a lot of the episodes are kind "post-modern"-they don't really answer many of life's big questions. This episode had a really important message that I wish I had realized while I was watching it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have always watched The Office on the shalow level of it being just a funny show. This episode caught my attention because it had an important message tied into the main plot. It was interseting to me that boss was the one trying to do the right thing and the sales man was trying to run the small business into the ground. It showed how fallen we still are because even though the boss had all the power to do the right thing he still gave into the empire.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great discussion about this episode, folks. Interesting what you can see with a different vocabulary and the insights of your classmates, huh? :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. I also thought this episode displayed a pretty clear empire vs kingdom contrast. I've been a fan of the office for quite some time now and I find it interesting how so often Michael is so close to doing the right thing and break away from the empire (usually), yet he winds up getting sucked back in. I think that this is a good example of how hard it can be to break the norm, not follow the empire, and participate in the kingdom. It isn't an easy thing, it can take guts, and it can mean making unpopular (or 'bad business') decisions.

    ReplyDelete
  6. When watching shows like the office its really easy to just view it as entertainment. However, when we take the time to reflect or watch it with "glasses" we tend to notice different things. Before taking this class one might of viewed this episode and said, "Michael is struggling with morality with his deciscion to use the information from the family paper company." Which in fact he is, however the struggle goes much deeper. After taking this class we can relize that its not just a struggle of morality, but a struggle between the empire and the kingdom. Too often in the business world this situation happens. The thirst for profits over powers the concern for any other humans. So what if it destroys a families well being, our stocks will be up. Just another example of where Christians can work to redeem the world.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I know this was posted a long time ago, but I didn't watch The Office as it aired on TV. I have discovered this amazing show on Netflix. I just watched this episode for the third time and noticed the theme that you guys are talking about. I googled a deeper meaning to this episode to see if anyone else picked up on it. That's how I discovered this post. I think there is also a theme that is not mentioned here about how the rest of the office is consumed with the debate over Hilary Swank. It is a debate that they are all really invested in and even Angela who does not want to be part of the debate gets sucked into. This debate is pointless and does nothing to really further civilization. I think this represents how our society is so absorbed in celebrity culture we have a blind eye towards the matters in life that really matter. Maybe if the office had been aware of the Prince family paper issue they could have interceded and taken Michael's side. I'm sure some of the sensical employees like Jim would have been able to see Michael's side (the Kingdom view) and been able to step in. Instead, they're all SO consumed in this pointless celebrity debate and don't even realize there's and actual important issue going on even though Michael is running around distressed. Instead of having a pointless debate over a celebrity, they maybe could have participated in an important debate that affected a family business and therefore that family's lives.

    I also liked Jim's theory about how we view celebrities as mythical creatures, therefore we dehumanize them, but that's a completely different topic.

    ReplyDelete