For my second cultural artifact, I listened to the fourth
album of Girls Generation. The alum came out on January 1st. Girls
Generation is a Korean pop idol that has taken the South Korea by storm ever
since their debut. The group consists of nine members (all female) who are very
beautiful and have slim bodies. Their new album is called ‘I Got a Boy’. Their
main song ‘I got a Boy’ has been number one on Korean music charts for all of
this month. I have liked this group since their debut and have never thought
about what they might have been implying in their songs and the different
concept of the albums. When the new album came out, I was able to notice things
that I would have never noticed with this class. What this album says about
women in society is to find the best looking man. Just like the title says, the
song talks about how they have got a man who is handsome and fantasy like. I
thought about this line and how it really undermines the role of women. In a
society where women and men are equal is all aspects, you have young women who
are singing that they are nothing without men. Why is it that men complete woman
in society? I know that God made both a man and a woman to be in one union together
but the empire has distorted that to something other. The bond and the relationship
between a woman and a man has become business like. It is all about saying to
one another, “you become what the empire portrays us to be or we cannot be together”.
To be truthful, there is not portrayal of the kingdom of God in the album what
so ever. I watched the music movie and it just emphasized what the empire
thinks about women. First thing that every woman should be is slender. All nine
members of Girls Generation are very slim and have “nice” figures. Second thins
that all woman should have is nice clothes and clothes that are revealing. The
music portrays the members in tight jeans or a shirt that does not cover their
bellies (the t-shirts were so short that it made me wonder if they ran out of
fabric while they were making the shirts). The third aspect is that they must
be pretty. To tell you the truth, the beauty corporations are thriving in South
Korea. From make up to plastic surgery, it is essential and almost a norm in South
Korea. I see no aspects of the kingdom of God in the music video or the album.
I am very patriotic, and even though I only lived in Korea for half of my life,
I have always been proud of my country and the hardships that they have overcome
after the Korean War. Industrially, Korea has climbed to the top but culturally
we are degrading ourselves every time we produce these kinds of music. How do
we see the world, with the glasses of apocalyptic or the empire? If we had the
choice (which we do) do you think that we would get rid of these useless things
the empire creates? Although I am embarrassed of myself for listening to these kinds
of music for such a long time, I guess this is all part of growing up and
realizing what is important and not.
I liked how you pointed out that distorted image of beauty that many women dream and their sole purpose to attract men. It is true when you see that most Korean high school students wants to get a plastic surgery for their graduation presents.
ReplyDeleteBut do you think pursing the beauty (physical appearance) is evil/worldly? How should Christian think about the physical appearance and the beauty in the frame of God's Kingdom?
I never thought of SNSD promoting the idea that women's sole purpose in life is to attract men. Now that you mention it, however, most of their songs and music videos and promotions make sense. I always just listened to their music because I thought it was catchy; I never thought about how they could possibly contribute to the whole messed-up beauty/fashion culture in Korea. After reading this, couldn't that apply to lots of other K-pop too--even the reversal of boy bands wanting to attract girls? I'm a huge Big Bang fan, and rarely a concert goes by when TaeYang hasn't ripped his shirt off. I never noticed how much the empire really does place a huge emphasis on physical appearance and finding a romantic relationship rather than a inward beauty and a relationship with God, like how the Kingdom does.
ReplyDeleteI remember the time when I first listened to SNSD's song and in that music video, "Into the New World," they weren't even that attractive. However as time went on and when they released "Gee" they were totally different people. Mentioning this change, I realized how big the beauty corporations in Korea have become. Two years ago in Korea, I was waiting to board a train. As I was waiting I spotted a lady and from the back she looked like she was in her twenties. She was slim and skinny, her clothes were what a person in her twenties would wear, and she had good hair. However a few moments later when she turned around she was this older lady about in her forties. This really really shocked me. Thinking of this now, I can notice that the empire puts a lot of emphasis on physical appearances. People imagine themselves looking more attractive which causes them to imagine for the empire. A question that I have here is that how can we pursue beauty in context of the Kingdom of God. Didn't God create beauty and isn't it natural for us to pursue beauty?
ReplyDeleteI just read about Girls Generation the other day, so I appreciate your analysis. I'd be careful to suggest that there isn't any portrayal of the Kingdom in here, though. In fact, it's wise to always look for the good, even in the midst of something seemingly unredeemable. We're often surprised by what we find.
ReplyDeleteHaving said that, I watched the video for "I Got a Boy" and was a bit bothered by the aesthetic of hyper-sexualized children. I obviously couldn't completely follow everything that was happening (particularly as I couldn't understand most of the lyrics), but the visuals were intriguing and disturbing. I'd need to spend a lot more time with it, though, to be able to make any kind of discerning judgement on the piece.
Thanks for looking deeper at this phenomenon!