America
the Beautiful, a film by Darryl Roberts, was clearly not a super high-budget or
professionally made movie, but I think it was able to accomplish a lot and
cover a lot of important material. One not-so-positive review of this movie was
written by Nick Pinkerton in The Village Voice. He opens his critical review with a pretty harsh statement: “The scattershot America the Beautiful recapitulates vintage Beauty Myth trumpery:
Beauty standards make us average frumps miserable and are the conspiratorial
invention of a cabal of Madison Avenue execs working in concert with
Patriarchal Hegemony.” While I agree that the film was slightly
scattered and definitely could improve in certain areas, I believe that it
provided an insightful view into America’s fashion industry, following the sad
story of Gerren Taylor who started as a supermodel at age 12 and after only a
few years was forgotten. The film also gave some terrible and surprising footage
and information about plastic surgery, the ingredients of cosmetics and their
effects, and other aspects of the beauty industry.
This film was very thought-provoking. It definitely made me think
more about what life is like as a model and changed my opinion of the fashion
industry. While I still am not a fan of the fashion industry, this film made me
realize just how much work being a model is and how hard it is, especially on a
young girl like Gerren. Though it may not change my physical actions in any
way, this film will definitely change the way I think and what I think about
America’s beauty/fashion industry and its effects on girls and women. And as
cheesy as it may sound, this film reminded me that everyone is beautiful in
their own way.
Thanks for sharing your comments, Hannah. Your reaction makes me think of this scene from The Devil Wears Prada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1LVptO7o4L8. I shop at thrift stores, but often find that the things I pull off the rack have Gap or J. Crew labels--then I realize how much the high fashion industry has trickled down to me and shaped what I find appealing. I don't have any easy answers here--just sharing the perspective that even those of us who don't have a direct role in the fashion industry are affected by it, and at times, I find that frustrating!
ReplyDelete